| Archives: | |
| Mon.9.21.2009 | When Should You Borrow? |
| Wed.9.16.2009 | Understanding How Credit Default Swaps Derailed The Financial Markets |
| Tue.9.15.2009 | Star Value Manager Sees Higher Stock Prices |
| Mon.9.14.2009 | Dogs Of The Dow Investment Strategy |
| Wed.9.9.2009 | Retail Investors Got Clobbered In The 2008 Stock Market Decline, Right? |
| Tue.9.8.2009 | Why Consumer Spending Is More Resilient Than Most Realize |
The Best Index Funds And Exchange-Traded Funds In my ongoing research and analysis of mutual funds, including index funds, I have been spending more time looking at exchange-traded funds. Remember that what ETFs fundamentally are — index funds — is nothing new. Being able to trade in and out of an index fund during the day is the primary difference of an ETF compared with an index fund. ETF's tradability does have its downsides because it may encourage excessive trading/market timing and because an ETF may be trading at a premium to its underlying value (which a layperson can't determine easily in the midst of a trading day). While ETFs and their advocates claim that ETFs hold lots of promise, my previous analysis found that the vast majority of ETFs have fundamental flaws. In previous articles, I've discussed how to use index funds to create simple but effective portfolios. Here are some additional insights and reminders: I disagree with folks who advocate using the S&P 500 index ETF as a "core holding." I have never cared for the S&P 500 index when investing in index funds, so I would not use that ETF. The reason I dislike it as an index investment is because it is capitalization weighted, which simply means that stocks in the index must be held in proportion to their market value in the index. Back in the late 1990s, during the technology stock bubble, the S&P 500 index was overloaded with bloated technology stocks selling at grossly inflated valuations, so S&P 500 index funds were forced to overweigh pricey technology holdings. (And, just prior to the late 2000s bear market, the same phenomenon happened with financial companies in the index.) I prefer broader market indexes such as Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF or even better — value-oriented ETFs discussed next. I lean toward value-oriented indexes and ETFs for the generally smoother ride and historically slightly higher total return. In the small-cap arena, I like the iShares Russell 2000 Value Index, to which I would add consideration of Vanguard's Small Cap Value ETF. In the foreign-stock arena, Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US is a solid core holding. To tap into the growth opportunities in developing countries, Vanguard's Emerging Markets ETF is an interesting although volatile (risky) holding. I also recommend Wisdom Tree's Emerging Markets Equity Income ETF, which has a far more generous yield and is less volatile. Write Eric Tyson, author of "Investing for Dummies" and "Personal Finance for Dummies" (Wiley) via e-mail: eric@erictyson.com. © 2009 Eric Tyson Distributed by King Features Syndicate Inc. |